I Defend The Accused http://idta.us Confessions of a prison public defender Tue, 22 Apr 2008 02:31:33 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.5 en Well, that’s one way to reduce crowded prisons. http://idta.us/archives/119 http://idta.us/archives/119#comments Tue, 22 Apr 2008 02:31:33 +0000 Idta http://idta.us/?p=119 Imagine if the “fine” for underage drinking was a tour of duty in Iraq! (Watch out, Jenna!) It hasn’t quite come to that, but our desperate military has expanded their definition of “a few good men” to include more people with felony convictions.

Under pressure to meet combat needs, the Army and Marine Corps brought in significantly more recruits with felony convictions last year than in 2006, including some with manslaughter and sex crime convictions.

]]>
http://idta.us/archives/119/feed
Client secrets http://idta.us/archives/118 http://idta.us/archives/118#comments Sun, 20 Apr 2008 15:41:11 +0000 Idta http://idta.us/?p=118 Attorney-client confidentiality has been getting a bad rap this week because of the Alton Logan case. (After lawyers for another man came forward to reveal that their client had admitted to them 26 years earlier that he committed the crime, Alton Logan was released this week on bond.)

Capital Defense Weekly reminds us about the importance of Client secrets & keeping your mouth shut.

]]>
http://idta.us/archives/118/feed
Man Freed After Lawyers Come Forward http://idta.us/archives/117 http://idta.us/archives/117#comments Sat, 19 Apr 2008 16:10:28 +0000 Idta http://idta.us/?p=117 I’m sure glad I haven’t had to keep a client’s secret confession for 26 years, knowing an innocent man was in prison for the crime.

Alton Logan’s family took up a collection in the lobby of the Cook County Criminal Courthouse and quickly came up with the $1,000 they needed to post bond.

At first, I loved that people at the courthouse contributed to help pay this man’s bond. (Do you get part of the bond back when you show up for the next hearing?) But then his family rode off in a black SUV to go get steak and lobster dinners?

]]>
http://idta.us/archives/117/feed
True to its name: The Winning Brief http://idta.us/archives/115 http://idta.us/archives/115#comments Thu, 10 Apr 2008 05:17:36 +0000 Idta http://idta.us/archives/115 umbre33.jpg I posted earlier this week about winning relief for our client recently at the Court of Criminal Appeals.

The book that helped me TREMENDOUSLY in organizing and finishing my brief was
The Winning Brief: 100 Tips for Persuasive Briefing in Trial and Appellate Courts.

]]>
http://idta.us/archives/115/feed
Why are you here? http://idta.us/archives/114 http://idta.us/archives/114#comments Wed, 09 Apr 2008 05:17:36 +0000 Idta http://idta.us/archives/114 umbre33.jpg One of my co-workers asked me today, “Why are you here?” I told him I want to be a better criminal-defense lawyer.

Tonight I finished reading The Best Defense, by Prof. Alan M. Dershowitz of Harvard Law School. In it, he wrote:

The public sometimes has difficulty distinguishing between the noble [defense attorneys] and the sleazy; the very fact that a defense lawyer represents a guilty client leads some to conclude that the lawyer must be sleazy. Being so regarded is an occupational hazard of all zealous defense attorneys.

The late Supreme Court Justice Felix Frankfurter once commented that he knew of no title “more honorable than that of Professor of the Harvard Law School.” I know of none more honorable than defense attorney.

]]>
http://idta.us/archives/114/feed
Writ granted. (Note to reporter: Look up *concur*) http://idta.us/archives/113 http://idta.us/archives/113#comments Wed, 09 Apr 2008 04:42:34 +0000 Idta http://idta.us/archives/113 umbre33.jpg Recently, the Court of Criminal Appeals granted a writ and overturned the wrongful conviction of one of my clients. That was a wonderful result, and it was heartening that all of the justices who participated in the decision agreed with us.

BUT, the Associated Press mis-reported the decision as “5 to 3″ when it was really 8 to 0: Five justices signed the majority opinion, and the other three concurred. (One justice didn’t participate.) Contrary to what the newspaper reports suggested, it wasn’t a close decision at all, and there wasn’t any dissent.

]]>
http://idta.us/archives/113/feed
Jury finds defendant “innocent by reason of insanity”? http://idta.us/archives/112 http://idta.us/archives/112#comments Tue, 01 Apr 2008 03:14:55 +0000 Idta http://idta.us/archives/112 umbre33.jpg This article about Rusty Yates starting a new family claims that his first wife was found “innocent” of killing their children.

Sloppy reporting like this misleads the public and could hurt people for whom “Not Guilty By Reason of Insanity” would be the appropriate result.

Andrea Yates was found innocent by reason of insanity in July 2006 and sent to a state mental hospital.

]]>
http://idta.us/archives/112/feed
Crime doesn’t play http://idta.us/archives/111 http://idta.us/archives/111#comments Wed, 26 Mar 2008 05:21:51 +0000 Idta http://idta.us/archives/111 umbre33.jpg At first I was intrigued by the headline Home Ransacked After Craigslist Hoax and thought maybe the homeowner had committed a hoax online, and someone tracked him down and retaliated. NOPE! Just a pretty mean trick. (And stupid. They’ll get him.)

P.S. Even though it must be awful for the homeowner, it’s hard not to smile as you watch the video.

Dozens of people descended on Robert Salisbury’s Oregon home after ads posted on Craigslist Saturday said his belongings — including his horse — were free for the taking. But the ads were a hoax. When Salisbury returned home, some people refused to stop taking his things.

]]>
http://idta.us/archives/111/feed
Prison succumbs to peer pressure http://idta.us/archives/110 http://idta.us/archives/110#comments Sun, 23 Mar 2008 02:19:27 +0000 Idta http://idta.us/archives/110 umbre33.jpg I imagine this is every parolee’s and released prisoner’s recurring nightmare: Officials say error freed ex-SLA radical. The parole board had already decided to let her go. So after some public criticism, they go looking for an excuse to snatch her back?

Criticism that followed Sara Jane Olson’s release Monday spurred a thorough review of her sentence and the timing of her parole, Chief Deputy Secretary Scott Kernan said at a news conference.

]]>
http://idta.us/archives/110/feed
Whose side is he on? http://idta.us/archives/109 http://idta.us/archives/109#comments Wed, 19 Mar 2008 05:11:07 +0000 Idta http://idta.us/archives/109 umbre33.jpg The headline suggests the rapist himself told the judge that he had HIV, but the story reveals it was actually the defendant’s *lawyer* who revealed that fact to the judge. And it cost the client a longer prison sentence!

That’s longer than he might have gotten usual for a rape conviction, and it’s because his attorney Ernest Staine told the court that Cardenas has HIV.

]]>
http://idta.us/archives/109/feed